Nashville Banner0 followersVerified Stay connected and personalize your Newswire experience.
Metro Lawyer Says Nashville Council Reduction Must be Approved by Voters
- Publisher
- Nashville Banner
- Topic
- Metro
- Location
- Tennessee, US
- Published
- Nov 16, 2026 · 12:02 PM
Las Vegas Newswire preserves the publisher's attribution and original-source link while adding publisher, topic and related-coverage navigation for readers.

With Metro officials beginning the process of reducing the size of the Metro Council at the state’s direction, a difference of opinion has emerged about how to move forward.
Some Republicans in the state believe the law, as written, requires the Metro Council itself to implement the reduction by resolution, without taking the question to Nashville voters.
But many Metro attorneys and elected officials believe that the law actually requires the opposite, a vote of the people.
The dispute could renew friction between the Republican-controlled state legislature and the liberal-leaning, nonpartisan Metro government.
At a special-called meeting of the Metro Council Charter Revision Committee on Friday, Metro Legal Director Tyler Yarbro did not equivocate.
She pointed to the existing state law, which directs the council to “take any legislative action required to effectuate this section by resolution receiving an affirmative majority vote of those present and voting, regardless of any provision of a charter or private act to the contrary.”
What’s missing from the “regardless” clause, Yarbro said, is “public act” or state law. So any changes must comply with state law, she told councilmembers. One such state law says that no amendment to a metropolitan charter “shall be effective until submitted to the qualified voters.”
Therefore, she opined, the Metro Council must submit a charter amendment to Davidson County voters for approval.
The next election at which such a referendum could be considered is the August 2027 Metro election, when voters would elect a new 40-member council. The Metro Charter requires amendments to be considered at regularly scheduled elections, not special elections. However, Yarbro added, the language of the state law allows the council to ignore that provision and hold a special election on the amendment.
A spring special referendum affirming a 20-member council in time for the regular August 2027 elections could appease the state, but a delay beyond that could ruffle Republican feathers and lead to legislative action when the Tennessee General Assembly returns in January. One such action could be an amendment adding “public acts” to the “regardless” clause, meaning the Metro Council would be expected to ignore the state law requiring a vote of the people on charter amendments and implement the change immediately.
A spokesperson for Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti told the Banner this week that “state law gives the Metropolitan Council of Nashville and Davidson County both the obligation and the authority to go ahead and implement a 20-member council.”
Attorneys from his office contemplated a voter referendum, however, when arguing before the Tennessee Supreme Court earlier this year. Councilmember Quin Evans Segall referenced the exchange during Friday’s meeting.
“Metro can propose a charter amendment and, as we understand it, plans to if this court affirms,” the state lawyer said.
House Majority Leader William Lamberth, an architect of the original 2023 legislation, said the change should be made “well ahead of the next election.”
“We look forward to working with Nashville leaders in good faith and with a shared commitment to better serving the people of Music City,” he told the Banner through a spokesperson. “I am confident they will take the necessary steps to implement the law in accordance with the Tennessee Supreme Court’s ruling. This is an opportunity to move forward constructively and provide Nashvillians with greater efficiency and clarity well ahead of the next election.”
Yarbro, however, said the law as written does not give the council the power to strip voters’ sole authority to amend the charter. Some councilmembers predict residents would sue Metro if it took that path.
“They may have opinions about what they thought they wrote, but I’m reading what they wrote,” Yarbro said.
The Charter Revision Committee, led by Chair Clay Capp, concluded the meeting by agreeing in principle on next steps. The committee will meet again on Tuesday. Preliminary discussions are already underway about setting up town halls to discuss the reduction in different corners of the county in the coming weeks. Councilmembers also suggested surveys and other forms of public engagement.
Yarbro and the councilmembers discussed a series of other looming questions about the process.
What happens if voters reject a charter amendment reducing the size of the council? The Metro Council would have to earnestly continue to push for such a change, Yarbro said. Courts would likely have further chances to weigh in if the dispute made it that far.
Is the Metro Council still a legitimate body at 40 members? And do its actions have legal authority? Metro must comply with the law, Yarbro said, and the council should not “dilly dally” in its pursuit of compliance. But as long as the council is working “in good faith” toward compliance, courts should respect that, Yarbro said.
What could the legislature do when they return to Nashville in January? Any number of things. Lawmakers could make minor tweaks that undermine Metro’s referendum argument, pressing for faster implementation. Yarbro also addressed the possibility that the legislature could simply enact the change itself, including by drawing new district lines. She said it’s difficult to offer an opinion on a hypothetical but referred to state constitutional protections against laws targeting a single municipality. The state has defended the council reduction law by saying it applies to all of the state’s current and future metropolitan governments, but specifically drawing map lines for Metro Nashville “creates a constitutional problem,” Yarbro said. Councilmember Russ Bradford said he was uncomfortable discussing strategy during Friday’s public meeting because observers could be “taking notes for January.”
Is there still time to hold a special election between now and the August Metro election? Unclear. Petitions for those races become available March 22. Presumably, any decision would need to be made by then. But as Tennessee election officials proved this year by enacting new district lines months after petitions became available, there can be some flexibility on election deadlines.
Could Metro appeal the Tennessee Supreme Court decision to the U.S. Supreme Court? Yarbro said “there are no more legal challenges to mount” and that there is no federal law being invoked.
The Supreme Court remanded the case to the trial court for further action. Does that mean Metro will get more guidance about how to implement the changes? No, Yarbro said, the trial court will not offer guidance or further opinion.
Can a charter amendment proposed to effectuate these changes include other changes to the charter? Yes and no, Yarbro said. If the amendment is proposed under the exceptions to the charter provided by the state law, it can only address the size of the council. So that likely means no changes to the role of the vice mayor or other wishlist items thrown about in recent weeks. An amendment could include more administrative tweaks to references to specific numbers of councilmembers in the charter, Yarbro said.
Could the council offer up a proposed amendment that cannot fail? Councilmember Kyonzté Toombs has been asking about a ballot question that offers multiple options for a 20-member council but doesn’t allow voters to reject the idea entirely. Yarbro said councilmembers will have to choose one option and put it to voters as a yes-or-no vote.
The post Metro Lawyer Says Nashville Council Reduction Must be Approved by Voters appeared first on Nashville Banner.
Article at a Glance
- Publisher
- Nashville Banner
- Author
- Stephen Elliott
- Primary topic
- Metro
- Coverage
- Tennessee, US
- Published
- Nov 16, 2026 · 12:02 PM
About the Publisher
Nashville Banner is the originating publisher of this Newswire report.
Coverage
This report is associated with Tennessee, US based on the location metadata supplied with the story or publisher profile.
Topics & Keywords
Primary topic: Metro
Related topics: Metro, Tennessee, Local News
Frequently Asked Questions
Who published this report?
This report was published by Nashville Banner and credits Stephen Elliott as the author.
What is the primary topic?
The story is categorized as Metro in the Newswire metadata.
What area does this story cover?
The available Newswire metadata associates this report with Tennessee, US.
What do you think about this story?
Share your perspective and join the conversation with other readers.
Discussion is hosted by Las Vegas Newswire. Publisher attribution and the originating report remain unchanged.
About Las Vegas News Publisher Network
Las Vegas News Publisher Network is the publisher-distribution network operated by Las Vegas News. It organizes reporting from participating publishers while preserving publisher attribution and links to the original source.
Nashville Banner0 followersVerified Stay connected and personalize your Newswire experience.
Loading recommendations…
