El Paso Matters0 followers✓Verified◆Authorized

Podcast: Voters said no to VATRE school tax proposals. Will layoffs and program cuts follow?

Nov 16, 2026 · 2:00 PM · Diego Mendoza-Moyers
NEWSWIRE CONTEXT Source details and discovery links added by Las Vegas Newswire.
Topic
Education
Location
Montana, US
Published
Nov 16, 2026 · 2:00 PM

Las Vegas Newswire preserves the publisher's attribution and original-source link while adding publisher, topic and related-coverage navigation for readers.

ADVERTISEMENT
Your Business Could Be Here — Less than $20/Day
Reach Las Vegas news readers, convention visitors & tourists.
Book this spot
Podcast: Voters said no to VATRE school tax proposals. Will layoffs and program cuts follow?

Never miss an episode. Subscribe to the El Paso Matters Podcast on YouTube, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. 


This episode was recorded Nov. 12, 2026.

Read the transcript

Diego Mendoza-Moyers: Today: the November 3rd election had some important impacts on public education in El Paso County. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Voters in three local school districts – Socorro, Ysleta and Tornillo – rejected proposals to increase property tax rates to generate additional funding for public schools. Their defeat leaves school districts facing some difficult financial decisions in the months ahead. We’ll talk about what exactly a VATRE election is and why local school districts put them on the ballot. 

Also, voters in other districts, including Canutillo, elected school board members who will help shape the future of public education there. 

So, what should we make of these election results? Why did voters reject the school funding proposals? And what happens next for the districts? 

ADVERTISEMENT

In a moment, I’ll talk with El Paso Matters education reporter Claudia Lorena Silva about the school-related elections and what they could mean for us going forward. 

First, this El Paso Matters podcast episode is brought to you by our podcast title sponsor, Tawney, Acosta and Chaparro, truck crash and injury attorneys. Their team of local, seasoned trial attorneys are ready to help if you’ve been injured in a crash. 

Also, you can subscribe to the El Paso Matters Podcast on YouTube or read our free reporting at elpasomatters.org. And many thanks to El Paso Community College Valle Verde Campus for the use of their studio podcast space. 

And before we start the discussion, we’d like to take a moment for a message from another one of our podcast sponsors. 

Meta is investing $10 billion to help build El Paso’s future. Because we don’t just build here, we invest here. Learn more at meta.com/buildingelpaso. 

Claudia, thanks for joining me. 

Claudia Lorena Silva: Hey, it’s nice to be back at EPCC. 

Diego: Yeah. I just talked with our colleague Elida about the city, county, and state elections and wanted to have you on to talk about school elections, which are kind of their own can of worms, it seems like. So, just wanted to get your expertise on this. 

Claudia: Yeah, my pleasure to go over them. I feel like this is kind of an election that doesn’t get as much attention, but I do think they are pretty important for the smaller communities that they affect. 

Diego: For sure. So, we’ll get into this and, listeners, I’m just going to ask you to stick with me here, because I want Claudia to explain to us what exactly is a VATRE, a voter-approval tax rate election, which several districts asked their voters for. Which, I want to get into the results and what they mean. But just tell us, like, what is this VATRE election and why do these school districts put it on the ballot for voters? 

Claudia: Yeah. So, I guess we’ll back up a little. I think more people are familiar with these propositions as Proposition A. That’s what most people saw on the ballot. But they are a VATRE, which is a voter-approval tax rate election. And, basically, what a VATRE is is it’s a way for school districts to generate more funding by essentially asking voters to do a little bit of changes with the tax rate and raise a portion of the tax rate. 

So, to give you a little bit of a lesson on how tax rates work is it’s broken down into two pieces. It’s broken down into the interest and sinking fund, which is normally used to pay for debt. And all of that is generally approved by voters in bonds, used for building schools. Like, the SAC 2, that was a bond and that is debt. So, that’s all something that has already been preset and approved by voters. 

Then there is the operation and maintenance, and that is used for the day-to-day operations of a school district. So, what a VATRE does is it authorizes the district to increase the operations portion of the tax rate beyond the state’s limit. So, the state every year sets a limit on what the operations portion is, and this is known as the voter-approval rate. So, Proposition A would have raised each of the districts’ portions of the tax rate above the voter-approval rate. 

And in Socorro, Ysleta and Tornillo, all of the voters basically said, “No, we don’t want you to raise the rate past the state-set rate.” When we look at Socorro, 57% of voters said, “no.” Ysleta, 56% of voters said, “no,” and at Tornillo, a whopping 70% of voters said, “no.” So, that’s a really high turnout. 

And to kind of explain what these propositions would have done – so, for Socorro, this would have generated about $4.9 million in revenue. Ysleta, it’s a much smaller proposition. It would have generated about $5.5 million. And Tornillo, much smaller district, only needed about $1.5 million. 

So, Socorro was going to use that money for quite a lot of things, actually. They were going to give employees raises. They were going to try to reduce class sizes. They were going to use it for long-term maintenance of the heating and cooling systems. 

One big thing that they were going to do is restart the elementary fine arts program, which, a couple years back, when they had layoffs, one thing that they had to do was cancel elementary school fine arts. So, right now, every student still gets elementary school fine arts as part of their curriculum, but their regular teacher teaches them that rather than having a dedicated music and art teacher. 

The other big thing is that they were going to use some of that money to offset health insurance increases. So, we know that health insurance costs have been going up for everyone. And a lot of districts have tried in the past to kind of shield their employees from those increases. And I think a lot of industries and employers try to do that. And that’s what they were going to use some of that money (for). 

For Ysleta, it’s a little bit different. They were going to use the $5.5 million as kind of this part of overall cost saving, or not really cost saving, but it was going to be part of this overall plan to get the district out of a financial catastrophe, essentially. 

Right now, the district is working on cutting costs and trying to generate as much revenue as possible. What they’re trying to do is they’re trying to avoid having to lay off employees. So, that money would have essentially just kind of added to their cost-saving plan. 

And Tornillo, they were going to just use that money to install seat belts in their school buses. And what’s interesting is that the state started requiring that all seat belts, or sorry, that all school buses have seat belts in them now. But a lot of the funding, a lot of districts think that hasn’t been adequate. So, they consider this an unfunded measure. So, that’s why they wanted to go to the voters and ask for this. 

Marty Robbins Recreation Center, 11620 Vista del Sol Drive, saw long lines of voters through the last day of early voting Friday, Oct. 30, 2026. Marty Robbins drew 10,671 voters during 12 days of early voting, almost 2,500 more than in the 2022 midterm election. (Cindy Ramirez/El Paso Matters)

Diego: Yeah, and I really appreciate that really thorough breakdown, kind of explaining where everything is and also the VATRE election. I think you’ve explained it to me before and I’m starting to understand. 

But, so, what do you think explains the opposition from voters across three districts, right? It wasn’t just voters in Socorro said, “no,” but it was universal opposition or majority opposition across three districts. What do you think explains that? 

Claudia: Yeah. Well, I guess, before diving into the opposition, maybe we want to explain why the districts are, where they got to the position of why they’re asking for this money. And it’ll help better understand why voters voted the way that they did. 

So, to kind of put it simply is when we look at Ysleta and Socorro, the districts are essentially running out of savings. They have been using their savings to operate for quite a while. So, they’ve been operating on a budget deficit. When you look at Socorro, they’ve been overspending for several years. Actually, I think for about 10 years, they were operating on a deficit, which means that their expenses were higher than the revenue that they were taking in. 

And one of the things is, for a long time, Socorro had increasing enrollment. So they were able to kind of shoulder that. But they’ve suddenly had decreasing enrollment. And that really took a big hit on the district. And that is where it started to hit on their savings. And over years, it started to go down and deplete them. 

For Ysleta, they’ve actually been in declining enrollment for decades. And what’s happening with them is that their teacher attrition – so, that’s the rate that their teachers and employees are retiring – has not really been fast enough to keep up with their declining enrollment. 

So, the students have been leaving faster than employees have been leaving. The district has, historically, when you look at it, they’ve been trying to close schools and do what they’re supposed to to try to cut savings and downsize. 

But from what they’ve explained is it just really hasn’t happened fast enough. And a lot of it has also had to do with board member decisions. 

In the past, like when you look at Ysleta, the district would recommend “Hey, let’s adopt a balanced budget.” But the board would say, “Oh, no, we are going to adopt a deficit because we want to offset the cost of health insurance or we want to provide stipends for our employees.” Which there’s no doubt that teachers and school employees deserve this. But it did put a financial strain on the district to right now, where they’re at is at the end of the school year, if they don’t substantially cut their expenses or get new sources of revenue, they could be almost out of savings. Not completely depleted, but they’ll be almost out, which is a very scary situation. 

Students leave Ysleta High School’s open campus during their lunch break, Aug. 17, 2026. (Corrie Boudreaux/El Paso Matters)

When we look at EPISD, they went into financial exigency earlier this year and they laid off a couple hundred employees to try to avoid that. So, it’s interesting that they are taking this approach to get so close to having no savings. 

But when we ask “Why were voters so opposed to this?” So, I think affordability is just a really big problem right now for voters, is a lot of them are struggling. They are having a hard time paying their own bills. And I think a lot of them are saying, “Hey, I need to live within a budget. You need to do that, too.” A lot of the voters that I talked to during early voting said that the districts, they need to just cut spending and live within their means. 

I think also another big issue is the ballot language. The ballot says that “This is going to be a tax increase.” So, it basically tells any voter, whether they’re educated on it or not, that their taxes are going to go up. 

Now, one thing that is interesting with Ysleta, it actually wasn’t going to increase taxes. It actually showed a negative number for a lot of people. It was actually taxes were still going to go down. And actually a lot of people weren’t going to be affected because of homestead exemptions. 

And in Socorro, there’s also a significant amount of people who wouldn’t have been affected by tax increases because they are either elderly or disabled or they are veterans who get homestead exemptions. But those people, they look at the ballot language and they say, “This is a tax increase” and don’t necessarily always get the full picture of what they’re voting for. 

Diego: So, just to be clear on the ballot, it said “This will be a tax increase” and then it had a negative number associated with that?

Claudia: Yeah. For Ysleta, it did have that. And I think that that’s very confusing to voters. It’s even confusing to me as a journalist when I first looked at that. It’s hard to explain what that actually means. And I think that was also a challenge for Ysleta. 

Xavier De La Torre, superintendent of Ysleta ISD, left, and Cruz Ochoa, Board of Trustees president, listen during a meeting of the Board of Trustees on June 12, 2024. (Corrie Boudreaux/El Paso Matters)

I think we saw that Socorro, they did a lot to try to educate their voters. And Ysleta did a lot as well. But it is an uphill battle because the vast majority of voters are not really going to see those messages. They’re just going to see the language on the ballot. And don’t actually know what the full outcome of their vote is going to be. 

Diego: Yeah. Again, I appreciate that breakdown kind of on the ballot language and maybe what motivated the opposition there. 

What happens now with these districts, right? Without these elections going through, or in the districts’ favor? Are layoffs on the table or sort of program cuts or something like that? What’s the impact of the district now, or the districts? 

Claudia: Yeah. Well, layoffs, that’s still a little bit uncertain. But I can say one of the certain things that will be coming is going to be more staffing cuts. And what that basically means is they are going to – all the districts are going to be doing this because of declining enrollment – but Ysleta and Socorro may do this a little bit faster than they initially expected, as they may downsize their staffing. 

And, usually, they do this through attrition. As employees retire, they basically reduce the overall number of staff that they have. They are offering a separation incentive for teachers who retire at the end of the year in December. And some teachers do, occasionally, like to retire after the holidays. So, that’s one way that they’re hoping to save money this school year is through some of those retirements. 

Socorro hasn’t mentioned anything about layoffs, but has said that they aren’t completely off the table if they aren’t able to cut expenses enough for the coming school year. I think what they’re focused on is next year, is they need to ensure they have a balanced budget, that they don’t dig into their savings anymore. And if they’re not able to do that through attrition and through just standard budget cuts, I think that layoffs are going to be the only other option. 

The other big thing that we saw at Socorro that is also affecting employees everywhere is health insurance premiums going up. Like I mentioned, they wanted to use, I think, about $5 million to offset the increased cost of health insurance premiums. Right now, we’re hearing that employees are already – it’s open enrollment period and they’re already looking at the different options as to whether they’re going to stay with the insurance of the district. And, we’re talking to different employees about how this may affect them. 

Democratic gubernatorial candidate Texas state Rep. Gina Hinojosa, left, and Democratic Senate candidate Texas state Rep. James Talarico, right, hold a campaign rally in Austin, Texas, Monday, Nov. 2, 2026. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)

I think it’s important to note that, as enrollment declines, districts are going to need to continue to keep cutting budgets. But despite the failure of these VATRES, some district leaders are still a little bit optimistic, especially since we saw the switch in Texas, a lot of the Democratic gains in state office. 

As we go into the legislative session, a lot of lawmakers that were elected, Gina Hinojosa, for one, they have promised to fund public education. So, there is some potential relief on the way. As the legislative session goes, we’re going to have to keep an eye on what kind of funding is going to come in. Is there going to be any relief for declining enrollment? Is there going to be any relief for rising health insurance costs and different things like that? 

But it is important to keep in mind that the relief won’t come probably for at least a year-and-a-half, maybe two years, because it does have to go through the legislative session, has to be approved by both the Texas House and Senate, and then it has to be approved by the governor. And then there’s still a whole bunch of other processes before the money actually gets distributed to school districts and actually starts making a direct impact. 

Diego: That’s really interesting. Yeah, I hadn’t thought about the impacts of the quote unquote “blue wave” right, on – I think we’re seeing now the impact across all these different levels of government, including now education, so that’s an interesting point as well. 

So, moving on, I did want to just touch a little bit on the school board races, which really it was Canutillo is the one with the – candidates in contested races. And, so, I guess, can you just talk about the results in Canutillo? And then maybe add, like, why do these school board elections matter, right? And sort of what are the tasks of school boards and just kind of an overview on the role of school boards and the results of the local elections for school boards recently? 

Claudia: Yeah. Well, the Canutillo ISD school board had an election and it was a pretty interesting race, mainly because we had a lot of familiar faces coming back to the board. 

So, one familiar face that we saw is the former superintendent, Pedro Galaviz. He resigned last year and he actually came back and was elected to the board. We had our incumbent, Cindy Andrade. She was already on the board and she was reelected.

Pedro Galaviz, superintendent of Canutillo Independent School District, attends a Board of Trustees meeting on July 23, 2024. (Corrie Boudreaux/El Paso Matters)

Former Trustee Blanca Trout, she was also elected to the board after, I believe she was gone for a four-year term, or no, sorry, she was gone for two years. And now she came back and she’s going to be on there for a four-year term. 

We also have a retired Canutillo ISD employee, and I believe she was also a former board member, Patsy Mendoza. She won an unexpired seat on the board, so she’s going to be there for two years. 

And, so, what board members do is, basically, their job is to oversee a school district and they have, – they’re kind of like the direct bosses of the superintendent. Their job is to hire and fire the superintendent of a district and they also do his annual reviews and evaluations. So, they decide what his goals are and will decide if he’s doing a good job or not accomplishing those goals. 

And if they think that he’s not doing a good job, and ultimately fire him and choose a new superintendent. I do think that the current superintendent was kind of a contentious topic during this race. And it does – it may actually be something that the board is going to be discussing a lot. I know that there is an item coming up on the agenda where they’re going to be discussing the superintendent, some of his previous work background and work history. So, that will be interesting to see what happens. 

It’s important to note that there is a lot of contentious history in this board. The district has a lot of history of different people disagreeing, arguments and just tension. So, it’s not really clear what will come out of it. I think, ultimately, this could end in the district getting a new superintendent, which could be a big mess because it would cost money in potentially a separation and doing a superintendent search. But it could not end up being anything and, ideally, everyone would get along and they give the superintendent some goals and things work out. 

Canutillo Independent School District adminstrative headquarters. (Corrie Boudreaux/El Paso Matters)

Diego: Yeah. You talked a little bit about the financial picture of Socorro and Ysleta, especially. Just curious if you can talk a little bit more about, as we see a new board take seat here for Canutillo, just where that district is at? How are you thinking about Canutillo, especially compared to some of the other districts in town? 

Claudia: I think Canutillo is doing a little bit better financially than they were doing in the past. They were one of the first districts to really start having financial problems and were operating on a deficit and having issues with worrying about depleting their savings. 

Something that they were really focused on was their declining enrollment and what they wanted to do to try to solve that problem is a bond. They actually had a bond election and they passed it and right now they are in the process of working on it. So, they are trying to renovate and fix up their schools. 

And I think it’s interesting to note that their district is in an area in El Paso that is actually growing in population. So, there actually are people moving into the Canutillo area. So, they do have the opportunity to start getting more students and kind of growing their enrollment numbers. And I think that that’s what they want to do with that bond. 

So, once those schools are ready, I think that’s what their plan is – to try to be on a more stable financial footing with enrollment. But, until then, I do know that they’re kind of on shaky grounds trying to keep their budget balanced and really just trying to keep expenses to the bare minimum. 

Diego: Yeah, it seems like a little bit of a familiar story at pretty much all the districts in town, kind of trying to watch spending and keep the budget in control and all that kind of stuff. 

I guess we’ll just end here, Claudia. Do you have any high-level thoughts on the school-related election results we saw? And just, was there anything you learned from how voters voted? Anything you took away from the election results as it relates to education in El Paso, generally? 

Claudia: Yeah, I mean, I think one of the big things, especially when we look at the Canutillo election and some of the other school board races, is I think that this race really shows that there needs to be more people becoming politically active in their school board in other areas of El Paso. 

The reason I say this is because Clint ISD also had a school board election scheduled, but all of their races were uncontested. So, there was actually no race and their names weren’t actually put on the ballot. Basically, the people who ran, they didn’t have any opponents, so they were selected. 

Clint is actually a larger district than Canutillo. So, there’s actually more people in that area who can put their hat in the ring, who could have something to say about how the district is operated. And I’m not saying that there’s anything wrong with how Clint is operated. But I think it just goes to show that we have this smaller community, it is on the Westside, and there are a lot of people who want to be active and are taking a part in the school board election and in school board meetings. 

And we have one on the Eastside that is a bit larger and there is almost no activity. And I think it’s just important that there are people active everywhere in the community so we can keep our elected officials accountable. 

Diego: Yeah. That really surprised me when you mentioned that Clint is larger as a school district than Canutillo. I would have just totally just guessed Canutillo was a bigger school district. And, I’ll say this, too, I guess, usually, when we talk education, we’re talking EPISD drama, but I guess they’ve escaped the spotlight for now. 

But I think that’s about everything I had to ask. I don’t know if you had any other thoughts that you wanted to add on the election results as it relates to schools? 

Claudia: No, just to add, we’re talking enrollment numbers. So, Canutillo has about 5,600 students and Clint has about 9,800. So actually, that was last year. So Clint has significantly more students than Canutillo, about 4,000 more. 

Diego: Wow. This is why we bring you on, Claudia, to just spit facts and share the truth on here. So, we appreciate it. 

But, anyway, so yeah, we’ll leave it there, Claudia. Again, just wanted to kind of run through some of these election results, maybe a little bit lower profile compared to the Senate race and governor’s race and so forth. But, obviously, impactful on the people of El Paso. So, just wanted to have you on and I think we’ll probably be talking education again here probably pretty soon. 

Claudia: Yeah, well, thanks for having me. It’s always a pleasure to talk education, and you have a great one. 

Diego: Thanks.

The post Podcast: Voters said no to VATRE school tax proposals. Will layoffs and program cuts follow? appeared first on El Paso Matters.

Article at a Glance

Author
Diego Mendoza-Moyers
Primary topic
Education
Coverage
Montana, US
Published
Nov 16, 2026 · 2:00 PM

About the Publisher

El Paso Matters is the originating publisher of this Newswire report.

View El Paso Matters on the Publisher Network

Coverage

This report is associated with Montana, US based on the location metadata supplied with the story or publisher profile.

Topics & Keywords

Primary topic: Education

Related topics: Education, Montana, Local News

Frequently Asked Questions

Who published this report?

This report was published by El Paso Matters and credits Diego Mendoza-Moyers as the author.

What is the primary topic?

The story is categorized as Education in the Newswire metadata.

What area does this story cover?

The available Newswire metadata associates this report with Montana, US.

READER DISCUSSION

What do you think about this story?

Share your perspective and join the conversation with other readers.

Comments

Discussion is hosted by Las Vegas Newswire. Publisher attribution and the originating report remain unchanged.

About Las Vegas News Publisher Network

Las Vegas News Publisher Network is the publisher-distribution network operated by Las Vegas News. It organizes reporting from participating publishers while preserving publisher attribution and links to the original source.

RELATED NEWSWIRE COVERAGEKeep reading
View all coverage
MORE FROM THIS PUBLISHEREl Paso Matters0 followers✓Verified◆Authorized
Publisher profile
PERSONALIZED NEWS DISCOVERYFor You
More For You

Loading recommendations…

Keep exploring Las Vegas NewswireMore reporting from publishers across the network
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

What happened in Vegas?

Straight to your email!

Local news, events, and top stories!

Install News App